$$ | Dive Bar | Waiting for first review

Bay Street Tavern in New York, NY

Bay Street Tavern is a dive bar at 1384 Bay Street, New York, NY, 10305 in New York, NY. See reviews, photos, directions, check-ins, crowd notes, hours, and contact details from RankTheBar users.

Dive Bar

Founding reviewer action

Write your take. Become a founding local reviewer.

Early takes help shape the local guide before it is crowded. Save the bar, build a night-out list, send it to a friend, or claim the founding bar profile if you represent the venue.

Write your take Save this bar Build night-out list Send to a friend Claim founding profile

Directions Open in app

Address1384 Bay Street, New York, NY, 10305

CityNew York, NY

Phone+1 718-720-3254

HoursMo-Th,Su 10:00-02:00, Fr-Sa 10:00-03:00

SourceOpenStreetMap / Overpass, verified 2026-05-05